Most tablet reviews compare specs. This one compares total cost of ownership over 3 years — because that’s what students actually care about. A $329 iPad can cost less than a $249 Android tablet over time. Or much more. Here’s the calculation.
The 3-Year True Cost of Ownership Analysis
Insight propio: True cost = device price + required accessories (stylus, keyboard, case) + any subscription costs.
| Tablet | Device Price | Stylus | Keyboard (optional) | 3-Year True Cost | Resale Value (3yr) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| iPad (10th gen, 64GB) | $329 | $79 (Apple Pencil USB-C) | $99–$299 | $507–$707 | High ($120–$180) |
| iPad Air M1 (64GB) | $499 | $129 (Apple Pencil 2) | $249 | $877 | Very high ($200–$280) |
| Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 FE | $299 | Included (S-Pen!) | $80–$130 | $379–$429 | Medium ($80–$120) |
| Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+ | $699 | Included (S-Pen) | $130 | $829 | Medium-high |
| Microsoft Surface Go 3 | $399 | $89 (Surface Pen) | $109 (Type Cover) | $597 | Low-medium |
Key finding: The Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 FE offers the lowest true cost (stylus included) for students who need stylus functionality. The iPad retains significantly more resale value, reducing effective cost if you sell after graduation.
iPad vs Android for College: Which Is Better?
| Category | iPad Wins | Android Wins |
|---|---|---|
| App quality | ✅ (more tablet-optimized apps) | |
| Note-taking apps | ✅ (GoodNotes, Notability) | (Samsung Notes is excellent) |
| Stylus included | ✅ (Samsung S-Pen at all tiers) | |
| Price/performance | ✅ | |
| Resale value | ✅ | |
| Integration with iPhone | ✅ (Handoff, Universal Clipboard) | |
| Customization | ✅ |
Best Tablets by Student Type
- Note-taking + handwriting (pre-med, law, arts): iPad + Apple Pencil. GoodNotes 5 is unmatched for handwritten note organization.
- Budget-conscious students who need stylus: Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 FE. S-Pen included. Best value with stylus on the market.
- Engineering/architecture (drawing + precision): iPad Pro or Samsung Tab S9+ — both have excellent pressure sensitivity.
- Productivity over everything (mainly typing): Surface Go 3 with keyboard. Runs full Windows — actual Microsoft Office, not mobile versions.
- Casual use (reading, video, light notes): iPad (10th gen) without stylus. $329 gets you a fast, high-quality display and years of software support.
The Note-Taking App Question: Which Tablet Works With What
The tablet is only part of the equation — the note-taking app you use determines how useful handwriting actually is for studying. GoodNotes 6 and Notability are the two most popular options for iPad, and both are iPad-only. GoodNotes has better PDF annotation and notebook organization; Notability has better audio recording sync and is slightly faster for quick note capture. Neither is available on Android or Windows, which is one of the most underreported reasons students end up preferring iPad for academic work despite the higher price point.
On Android, Samsung Notes is genuinely excellent — better than most people expect. It syncs across Samsung devices, supports AI features like auto-layout and handwriting conversion, and exports cleanly to PDF. The gap between Samsung Notes and GoodNotes has narrowed considerably since 2023. For students not already invested in an Apple ecosystem, Samsung Notes on the Tab S9 FE is a fully capable academic note-taking setup at a lower total cost than any iPad configuration with stylus.
Do You Actually Need a Tablet? The Honest Answer
A tablet is a supplement to a laptop, not a replacement. Students who try to use a tablet as their only device almost universally run into friction points: full versions of software like Excel, Matlab, AutoCAD, and most IDEs don’t run on iPadOS or Android tablets. Writing long papers is uncomfortable without a keyboard. Multitasking with research materials open alongside a document is more limited than on a desktop OS. The Surface Go 3 is the main exception — it runs full Windows — but its performance caps out quickly for demanding tasks.
The students who get the most value from a tablet fall into a specific pattern: they already have a laptop, they take a lot of handwritten notes in class, and they read a significant amount of PDF content (textbooks, papers, case studies). If that describes you, a tablet with a stylus is worth the investment. If you mostly type your notes and do your reading on a laptop screen, the tablet adds cost without adding proportional utility.
Storage: How Much Do Students Actually Need?
Most tablet configurations start at 64GB or 128GB. For students using the tablet primarily for notes, PDFs, and light app use, 64GB is sufficient — note-taking apps are small, and PDF textbooks are typically 50–200MB each. The storage question becomes relevant if you plan to store video projects, large datasets, or an extensive photo library locally on the device. Otherwise, cloud storage through Google Drive, iCloud, or OneDrive covers the gap at a lower cost than upgrading to a higher-storage configuration at purchase.
One practical note on storage for iPad specifically: Apple doesn’t offer expandable storage via microSD. What you buy is what you get. Samsung tablets, including the Tab S9 FE, accept microSD cards up to 1TB, which means you can start with the base storage configuration and expand cheaply later. For students on a budget who aren’t sure how much storage they’ll need, this is a meaningful practical advantage for the Android side of the comparison.
👉 Also see: Best Laptops for College Students Under $500